Yale University publishes press release on the Danish cartoons

by Claudia on August 26, 2009 · Comments

It also contains the statements of some of experts who advised not to publish the Danish cartoons. It ends with a contradiction:

The University has no speech code, and the response to “hate speech” on campus has always been the assertion that the appropriate response to hate speech is not suppression but more speech, leading to a full airing of views.

So, why didn’t they air the cartoons?

The decision rested solely on the experts’ assessments that there existed a substantial likelihood of violence that might take the lives of innocent victims.

But didn’t they tell us that “response to hate speech is not suppression, but more speech”? They don’t make any kind of reflection on why, in this case, it is different or why they aren’t publishing other great paintings which also depict Mohammed and have nothing to do with the Danish cartoons.

Cross-posted from T&P (with some updates on the matter).

Related posts:

  1. Yale censors cartoons depicting Muhammad, citing fears of violence
  2. US: Yale Press Bans Images of Muhammad in New Book
  3. Islamic terrorists attack Danish Embassy in Pakistan
  4. Denmark: Politician says muslim nations should apologize, not the Danish
  5. Danish women held captive abroad
  6. Denmark: Saudi lawyer demands apology over publication of Muhammad cartoons
  7. Minnesota man faces fine for anti-islam cartoons
  8. Islamist leader: Blow up Danish embassies, kill the ambassadors, slaughter cartoonists
  9. University of California muslim students disrupt speech by Israeli Envoy
  10. Two Chicago Men Facing Terror Charges For Plotting to Bomb Danish Newspaper
Want automatic updates?
4 choices: Twitter, Facebook, RSS feed or get daily email updates
  • I think you're right, Yale caved and contradicted what has always been their assertion. Religion - Islam included - shouldn't be exempt from criticism and frank discussion. If your "faith" is too weak to take a few slaps in the kisser or cartoons and satire from non-believers, then maybe it's not worth defending in the first place. I'm looking at you, Cargoists.
blog comments powered by Disqus